Almond Paste All Year: A Bentham Case Against the December Box
Photo: Phsyco ant at English Wikipedia, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Marzipan has a calendar problem. For eleven months of the year it sits at the back of the cupboard, a leftover baton from a Christmas cake, a few dusty fruits in a box. Then December arrives and it is everywhere: under the icing, inside the stollen, rolled into little potatoes and painted in unnatural colours. By January it has vanished again, as if almond paste were a seasonal employee.
This is unfair. Marzipan is not a Christmas decoration. It is a proper ingredient with a long history, a distinct texture and a place in some of the best cakes in the country. Bentham should be eating more of it, and not just when the tree is up.
The December Ghetto
Part of the problem is the way marzipan is sold. It arrives in blocks, wrapped in plastic, next to the icing sugar and the glacé cherries. It is associated with fruitcake, which is itself a once-a-year enthusiasm. People who would happily eat a Bakewell tart will tell you they do not like marzipan, without noticing that they are arguing with the same family of flavours.
The other problem is sweetness. Bad marzipan is cloying, perfumed and pasty. Good marzipan is nutty, slightly bitter and almost savoury at the edges. If your only experience of marzipan is a cheap slice of Christmas cake with a thick yellow lid, you have not really had marzipan. You have had sugar paste with almond essence.
What Marzipan Actually Is
Marzipan is ground almonds and sugar, usually with a little egg white or glucose to bind it. That is it. The best versions taste of roasted almonds rather than perfume, and they have a texture that yields rather than crumbles. It should be marzipan, not fondant in disguise.
Because it is simple, it is versatile. It can be rolled thin and laid over a cake, shaped into fruits, grated into a tart, or used as a filling for dates and figs. It can be toasted, which brings out the almond flavour and reduces the sweetness. It can be cut with citrus zest or a pinch of salt. Marzipan is not a one-trick pony. It is a workhorse that has been dressed up as a reindeer.
The Battenberg Defence
If you need a year-round argument for marzipan, look at the Battenberg. Pink and yellow squares of sponge, stuck together with jam, wrapped in a thin coat of almond paste. It is a cake that has made peace with its own absurdity. It is also delicious, and it is available in bakeries and cafés all year round.
A good Battenberg depends on the marzipan. Too thick and it dominates; too thin and it tears. The best versions have a layer thin enough to chew but thick enough to taste. In Bentham, a Battenberg on the counter is a quiet reminder that almond paste does not need tinsel to be worth eating.
The Bakewell Case
The Bakewell tart is the other great almond ambassador. It is not marzipan, strictly speaking, but it belongs to the same family: ground almonds, sugar, eggs, jam. If you like a Bakewell, you like the flavour of almonds. Marzipan is simply the next step, the concentrated version.
This is why the anti-marzipan position is so inconsistent. People who order Bakewell tarts and almond croissants will recoil from a marzipan fruit. The difference is not flavour. It is format. Marzipan fruits look old-fashioned, and old-fashioned things are easy to dismiss. But an almond paste rolled into a small pear and dipped in chocolate is no stranger than a fondant fancy.
The Counter Trade
Bentham’s sweet counters still sell marzipan fruits, often in little paper cases. They are not fashionable. They are not the thing you photograph for social media. But they are exactly the sort of small indulgence this town does well: a few bites, a cup of tea, a quiet moment by a window.
The same counters sell marzipan bars, chocolate-covered almonds and the occasional Battenberg. These are not Christmas items. They are everyday items that happen to peak in December because that is when we remember them. The rest of the year, they sit there, waiting.
A Year-Round Bentham Manifesto
So here is the case: marzipan should be eaten in February, when the light is grey and the Christmas cake is gone. It should be eaten in June, with strawberries, as a contrast to cream. It should be eaten in September, grated over apples, and in November, when the first proper frost arrives and the bakery counter feels like a refuge.
Ask your baker for a marzipan twist. Buy a Battenberg instead of a brownie. Try a marzipan fruit with your afternoon coffee and see whether the old-fashioned thing still works. It usually does.
The Verdict
Marzipan is not a Christmas cameo. It is an almond paste with a calendar problem, and the solution is not to eat more of it in December. The solution is to eat it in the other eleven months too. In Bentham, that should be easy. The counters are there. The tea is hot. The only thing standing in the way is a habit.